A TRO (a Temporary Restraining Order) has been granted against the Sand Land Mine from the Appellate Division.
This prevents mining deeper until the Supreme Court Judge issues a decision on our preliminary injunction. Written in the Sag Harbor Express article below, “As part of the modified permit, Sand Land must establish a groundwater monitoring plan that requires testing groundwater samples at the mine site on a quarterly basis. All test results must be submitted to the DEC for review.”
This is some great news! But our work is not over yet. The NCC will not rest until we are assured of contamination cleanup and environmentally safe/legal operations. The DEC must be held accountable for their flip-flop settlement and not recognizing the contamination reported by Suffolk County Dept. of Health Services.
REMINDER to contact the DEC:
Deadline: April 19, 2019
The April 19th deadline for public comments on the DEC’s flip -flop on issuing a permit for the Sand Land Mine is quickly approaching. The DEC is not acting in the best interests of those who use water on the East End. WE NEED A PUBLIC HEARING ON THIS MATTER AS WE HAD ON OCTOBER 20, 2015. PLEASE SEND A NOTE TO THE DEC BEFORE FRIDAY, APRIL 19. Below are a few sample notes that you may wish to copy. Please feel free to share this note with your friends and neighbors.
NYS DEC Region 1, Division of Environmental Permits
SUNY @ Stony Brook
50 Circle Road
Stony Brook, NY 11790
Please cc: ThieleF@assembly.state.ny.us and JSchneiderman@southamptontownny.gov and NoyacCivic@optimum.net
We demand a Public Hearing immediately on the recent issuance of a permit for the Sand Land Mine its operations. The Suffolk County Health Department found that the Mine’s activities have contributed contaminants to our groundwater beneath the Mine. Excessive lead, iron, manganese, carcinogens and pesticides are some of the contaminants cited in the June 29, 2018 Health Department’s report. As residents in the area who rely on this aquifer as our source of water, we have many questions as to why the DEC issues this permit contrary to the DEC’s removal of the Mine’s permit in September, 2018. We want Commissioner Basil Seggos and Region 1 Director Carrie Gallagher to answer our questions and hear our concerns at this public hearing.
Why did the DEC issue a permit to a known polluter, the Sand Land Mine, on March 20, 2019, when in September, 2018 the DEC modifies the Mine’s permit citing its contamination of our aquifer? I demand that the DEC hear our concerns and answer our questions at a Public Hearing immediately.
How can the DEC, the protector of our environment, issue a permit to a known polluter, the Sand Land Mine? In September, 2018, the DEC modified the Mine’s permit because of the contamination of our aquifer beneath the Mine. The Suffolk County Health Department reported the contamination caused by the Mine’s operations in a report issued on June 29, 2018. In addition, the DEC states in this letter that there is “de minimus” sand left in the Mine. So how can the Mine excavate 40 feet deeper if there is no sand left to mine? For these reasons, we demand a Public Hearing on the DEC’s issuance of a permit on March 20, 2019 to the Sand Land Mine. The community has many questions and concerns the the DEC has not answered.
On October 20, 2015 the DEC had a public hearing on the Sand Land Mine’s application to expand. Now that the Mine has been given another permit, despite the DEC’s permit modification in September, 2018, we demand another public hearing immediately.
March 27, 2019
Outrage over DEC settlement with Sand Land Mine!
On March 22, several members from the NCC, Bridgehampton CAC, and Save Sag Harbor met with Assemblyman Fred Thiele to ask what can be done regarding the recent DEC settlement with Sand Land Mine. We also attended the Town Council meeting on March 26, but more help is needed from residents to protect our precious water.
The NCC is urging all residents to :
Tell the Town Board to Demand a Public Hearing with DEC Commissioner Basil Seggos and DEC Region 1 Director Carrie Gallagher in attendance.
Flood the DEC and every elected official with comments.
Tell Southampton Town Board that they need to legally challenge the settlement.
See these articles for more info:
East Hampton Star (D.E.C. to Let Sand Land Mine Stay Open By Johnette Howard | March 18, 2019 - 2:48pm)
The Independent (Deal Gives Sand Land Eight More Years, March 19, 2019 By | Stephen J. Kotz )
27 East (DEC Grants Sand Land Eight More Years Of Operation In Settlement Mar 19, 2019 4:19 PM By Anisah Abdullah
Sag Harbor Express (Sand Land Reaches Settlement Involving Eventual Closure of Mine, By Christine Sampson, March 15, 2019)
February 26, 2019
Dear Town Attorney, Supervisor Schneiderman, and Southampon Town Board -
Thank you for the detailed and concise email following up on our meeting. In light of a recent notice from Town ZBA that Sandland’s Certificate of Occupancy (CO) is still in question and was again postponed, we have many questions...
The obvious abuse of operation rights has led to a public and environmental health issue that is not being remedied. As we delve further, there are several facts that are upsetting in that the Town has seemingly not taken more enforcement and action on.
Based on the Suffolk County Health Department 2018 report and investigator’s photo/video, it is clear that Sandland has contaminated the aquifer and unregulated practices are occurring.
The CO, dated 2016 (click here to view copy of CO) seems contradictory to the Town’s statement that new mines are not allowed.
This CO states they can operate their sand mine including the storage, sale and delivery of sand, receipt of trees, brush, stumps leave and OTHER DEBRIS. [so they can essentially, legally operate as a dump! What defines “other debris”?] BUT It goes on to state: However, the processing of the above (and they list more than was listed in what is accepted) is specifically prohibited. [so here they have clearly been operating illegally since this 2016 CO by accepting and processing what was specifically prohibited.]
Many questions remain:
How much has the Town received in fines from illegal practices by SL? (Can we FOIL a record of this?)
Why didn’t the Town apply to get the fees from the Appellete court ruling and why hasn’t the Town collected the $6,000?
Why hasn’t the Town acted on zoning and variance violations? i.e. A scale is 19 inches from property line, etc.
Why isn’t Sand Land continuing to be fined?
What has the Town done to ensure SL meets code?Can the Town take the authority to amend the CO?
Has the Town seen a site plan to validate this newly requested CO that keeps appearing on ZBA docket?
How is it legal for Sand Land to keep applying to the ZBA, have hearings postponed, and still operate?
Can a CO be revoked due to illegal and harmful environmental practices?
Why was the illegal processing allowed for so long?
Who is monitoring recent activity to be sure it meets environmental standards? (Recent grading, storing and sale of material and reclamation)
Has the Town been in contact with the DEC over the problems or was the Town’s last contact with the DEC the Supervisor’s letter in July?
Why hasn't the Town been contacting the DEC about the myriad of other illegal and unregulated polluting practices?
NYS law (Oct2018) allows Town of Southampton to require monitoring of groundwater impacts resulting from mining/reclamation of mining. What is ToS doing to adopt and enforce the law?
What is being done to clean up the site? (i.e. remediate the contaminated pools, etc.) Or is the Town ok with letting this contamination sit and seep into the environment?
We look forward to hearing back with answers to these questions.
The Noyac Civic Council
– February 15, 2019 –
The Group for the East End, the Citizens Campaign for the Environment, and the Noyac Civic Council have led the battle charge to clean up the contamination in our aquifer. Here is a letter, dated Feb. 7, 2019, from Bob DeLuca, President of the Group of the East End, worth reading. Below is another letter attached also worth your time. I urge you to write and/or call our Town Supervisor, Jay Schneiderman, and the Town Council to get them to act. Feel free to write to the Sag Harbor Express ( firstname.lastname@example.org) and the Southampton Press (email@example.com) on this issue. Thank you for your time and interest in our hamlet and the health of our groundwater.
Elena Loreto, President NCC
Dear Supervisor Schneiderman and Town Board Members,
Among the various issues we are working on with respect to water quality protection, we are currently pursuing the establishment of local laws that will improve groundwater monitoring for State-regulated sand mines and vegetative waste processing facilities.
In brief, and as you know, over the last several years, research conducted by the Suffolk County Health Department and the NYSDEC has confirmed the presence of significant groundwater contamination resulting from the operation of sand mines (in particular, those with ancillary industrial processing operations also operating on the premises).
In response to this emerging source of contamination, Assemblyman Fred Thiele and Senator Ken LaValle have thankfully and successfully gotten an amendment approved by the New York State Legislature and signed by the Governor, that, for the first time, will allow local governments to impose groundwater monitoring requirements on state-regulated sand mines and mine reclamation operations.
The attached letter outlines this issue and recommends that Southhampton Town adopt such necessary local laws as may be required to establish meaningful groundwater monitoring requirements for sand mines and for vegetative waste processing facilities under Town jurisdiction.
Late last week, I sent a similar request to the East Hampton Town Board and have already received some positive feedback on the Board’s interest in moving forward with this measure.
For your additional information, I have attached a copy of Assemblyman Thiele’s bill, which was ultimately signed into law last year. Also, I would be happy to provide you with the full studies issued by the SCDHS, which document the groundwater contamination associated with open pit mines and vegetative waste processing facilities. Given what we have already seen in Wainscott and Noyac, we believe there is a critical need to get out ahead of these potentially polluting uses for the future, especially because the NYSDEC is presently doing very little to contain the potential pollution associated with these industrial land uses.
We note that this endeavor would be highly consistent with the Town of Southampton’s duly-adopted, 2013 Sustainability Element of its Comprehensive Plan (aka Southampton 400+), which sets the following clean water goal for Southampton Town:
"Restore and protect the Town’s ground and surface waters to ensure their ability to support public health and the maritime, recreational and resort activities that underpin Southampton’s way of life and economy.” (p.42)
Thank you for taking the time to review this letter. I would be happy to work with the Town Board or any individual member who wishes to consider further action on this matter, which I hope you will.
All the best,
– December 10, 2018 –
Please click to read:
The NCC will be waiting for further clarification on the language therein, but it seems the Chief Administrative Law Judge, James T. McClymonds, has denied Sand Land’s motion to renew and reargue, BUT also put the responsibility back on the Town of Southampton ZBA. See excerpt…
…In this case, the Town ZBA appears to be the ultimate municipal authority vested with jurisdiction to determine whether applicant’s proposed mine expansion is authorized under the Town Code without any further Town approval, or whether a variance is required before the expansion is allowed…
What you can do:
Tell the DEC to address the CONTAMINATION and the Town ZBA to deny the expansion permit once and for all.
The DEC needs to protect our health and safety.
Call or email Governor Cuomo: (518) 474-8390.
September 5, 2018...
NCC President's Letter to Assemblyman Thiele, Jr., Legislator Fleming, Mr. Sapp, and Supervisor Schneiderman. cc. Basil Seggos, Bob Deluca, Adrienne Esposito, James Tomarken:
I am deeply concerned by the DEC ’s lack of response to the Suffolk County Health Department’s report on the water contamination beneath the Sand Land Mine.
On behalf of the 550+ members of the Noyac Civic Council, I implore you to meet with Commissioner Seggos to find a solution to this problem. I urge you to demand that NO PERMITS shall be issued to the Sand Land Mine by the DEC, the business that, as stated by the Health Department, has negatively affected our aquifer. Time is of the essence. Please let me know when you can arrange this meeting.
Elena Loreto, President Noyac Civic Council
– August 12, 2018 –
*** URGENT CALL FOR ACTION ***
Decision on the Renewal of Sand Land Mine’s Permit is forthcoming...
Governor Cuomo must be engaged to make sure the NYSDEC does its job of protecting our water: Request that Sand Land/Wainscott Sand & Gravel located in the Town of Southampton NOT be issued a renewed permit in November.
Gov. Cuomo needs to hear directly from the public.
NCC members should feel free to remind the Governor that:
Waste processing on the site is illegal under Town Code and supported by Court ruling
The mine is out of sand.
The operations at the site have already contaminated groundwater
The facility's operations threaten the drinking water in a State-designated Special Groundwater Protection Area.
Despite all of these objective realities, the Governor's DEC has done nothing but ignore the public while actively and willfully concealing readily observable problems at the site — despite irrefutable third party agency data (SCDHS) that the site is in fact contaminating the aquifer.
The aquifer is everyone’s source of water on the East End, even Suffolk County Water.
Note: The DEC has declined to attend our meetings, nor has anyone returned phone calls.
– July 2018 –
Sand Land Mine Sits atop our Sole Source Aquifer. Please read the Final Report from Suffolk County Department of Health Services. From the report:
The vegetative waste management activities on the Sand Land site have had significant adverse impacts to the groundwater. The analytical results from the groundwater samples indicate impacts of elevated metals concentrations (in particular manganese and iron) and other groundwater impacts that are consistent with results observed at other VOWM sites throughout Suffolk County1, which have been attributed to the VOWM activities performed at these sites. Detrimental groundwater impacts were observed at the Sand Land site despite the significant depth to groundwater (137 to 154 feet below grade). Additionally, data from wells installed on the site suggest the presence of downward vertical groundwater flow component, indicating this is a vital groundwater protection area. This also suggests that contaminants released on the site may flow into deeper portions of the aquifer.
The SCDHS should complete sampling of the private wells in the survey area to assess possible impacts to private drinking water wells to the west and northwest of the site. Based upon the groundwater information obtained in this investigation, and the results of the private well testing thus far, the extent of the private well survey area previously determined is appropriate.
Suffolk County Legislator Bridget Flemming released the following statement 6/29/18:
"This thorough report describes a groundwater investigation that is the culmination of years of effort by advocates and officials who have tenaciously fought for the protection of our invaluable aquifer, the sole source of drinking water on Long Island, and a critical resource for current and future residents. The report demonstrates definitively that the ongoing activities at this site are polluting our drinking water now and for future generations. The conclusions of the report must be met with swift action. The evidence shows significant negative groundwater impacts from the waste management activities occurring at the site, including manganese exceeding drinking water standards by almost 100 times and iron by over 200 times, as well as elevated levels of contaminants such as thallium, sodium, nitrate, ammonia and gross alpha, despite the significant depth to groundwater at the site. It is therefor imperative that the activity cease unless mitigation measures to effectively prevent groundwater impacts are identified and implemented.
I am grateful to County Executive Steve Bellone, Commissioner Tomarken, and the entire SCDHS staff for their tenacious and highly professional pursuit of an accurate assessment of the groundwater impacts of the activities at the Sandland site. I look forward to continuing to work with officials at all levels of government to ensure that this unacceptable pollution of our drinking water source comes to an end.”
ACTIONS proposed by Assemblyman Fred Thiele:
All levels of government must act and must act now, the assemblyman demanded. He compiled a list of actions that must be taken immediately:
1. We cannot wait until April for the Suffolk County Department of Health Services to release its report on the contamination. The testing was done months ago and the SCDHS has had the raw data for weeks. Their report must be made public in the next two weeks.
2. The SCDHS must also begin to survey for contamination by testing all drinking wells that are down gradient of the contamination.
3. The State DEC must launch a full environmental investigation to determine the full extent of contamination at this location.
4. The State DEC must take action to stop the processing of vegetative waste and other industrial activities until the extent of the contamination is known.
5. The State DEC must reject any expansion of the sand mine at this location
6. The Southampton Town Supervisor must exercise his authority under State Law and inform the State DEC that mining is a prohibited activity under the Southampton Zoning Code.